← All essays

Whatever Purity Meant

A few minutes earlier, I hadn't known how to hold a steak knife. Now I was old enough to promise what I'd do with my body for the rest of my unmarried life.

Jennie Denney

Jennie Denney

Sep 20, 2026

“My boyfriend and I had sex, and we don’t know what to do.”

Her parents were missionaries. We were still in high school.

I don’t remember where we were when she told me. I don’t remember the expression on her face or whether she asked me to keep it a secret. I wish I remembered what I said to her. I wish I knew whether I had offered her anything that felt like kindness.

I do remember telling my parents. That was what you did with information that felt too heavy to hold by yourself. You handed it to someone with more authority than you and trusted that they would know what to do with it.

I don’t remember my parents’ exact words, but I remember the message that landed in me.

She had ruined her parents’ lives. If anyone found out, they might not be allowed to remain missionaries. Everything they had worked for could be taken away because of what their daughter had done.

I don’t remember anyone asking whether she was okay. Maybe they did. That part is gone. What stayed was the understanding that one decision about her body could reach across the world and pull her parents home.

Her body had the power to undo their lives, and the thought lodged somewhere inside me.

There were other messages, too. Smaller ones. Ordinary enough that they didn’t feel frightening at the time.

Cover your shoulders before you go into church. Pull your shirt up. Make sure nothing is showing. Don’t wear anything too low. Cover your belly. Make sure your pants aren’t too tight or your skirt or shorts too short. Don’t wear too much makeup.

There were books like Gift-Wrapped by God, I Kissed Dating Goodbye, and The Bride Wore White. There were all the Christian romance novels I read, Janette Oke and others, where the good women waited and the good men chose them. There were purity balls, concerts, and sermons.

Purity always seemed to end with someone being chosen. Impurity seemed to end with everyone finding out.

For my sixteenth birthday, my dad took me to a fancy steakhouse. I don’t remember what I wore, but I remember the dimly lit room and how crowded the restaurant was. I was hungry and excited when the food arrived. Then my dad made fun of the way I was holding my knife.

I tried to adjust my hands, suddenly aware of how awkward they looked and how obvious it was that I didn’t belong in a restaurant like that.

Then he gave me a small silver ring with a heart on it.

It was a promise ring. I would wear it as a sign that I planned to remain sexually pure until marriage, whatever that meant. I’m still not sure I know.

One day, I would take it off and replace it with a wedding ring. My body would pass safely from my father’s protection into my husband’s keeping, still wrapped, still unopened, still worthy of being received.

I slipped the ring onto my finger.

I don’t remember anyone asking whether I wanted to make the promise. I don’t remember needing to be asked. By sixteen, the answer had already been placed inside me. Of course I would wait. Of course I would be good. Of course I would protect the people I loved from the shame of having a daughter who didn’t.

I was old enough to make a promise about what I would do with my body for the rest of my unmarried life. A few minutes earlier, I hadn’t known how to hold a steak knife.

I wore the ring home. I kept wearing it.

I don’t think my dad intended it to frighten me. I think he believed he was giving me something beautiful. Maybe he wanted me to understand that I was valuable. Maybe he thought the ring would protect me from choices that could hurt me. For a long time, I tried to remember it only that way.

But shame doesn’t always arrive sounding cruel.

Sometimes it arrives in a velvet box. Sometimes it is handed to you across a table by someone who loves you. And sometimes, you slide it onto your own finger.

The ring became part of my hand. It went everywhere my body went, a small circle of metal carrying the weight of God, my father, the church, and a future husband whose face I couldn’t yet imagine.

I think again about my friend. I wonder how long she carried what had happened before she told me. I wonder whether she was afraid I would see her differently. I wonder what it cost her to trust me and how quickly I gave her story to someone else.

There is another story underneath this one.

I can feel it pressing against these words, asking to be told. It’s the reason I remember the ring. It’s the reason I still feel something tighten in me when I think about purity, confession, and the fear of disappointing the people whose love mattered most.

It’s a story about what happened when everything I had been taught about bodies, family, shame, and reputation stopped being theoretical.

I don’t feel free enough to tell it yet. I hope someday I will.